In 2008, WN previewed the Orioles upcoming season with tales of woe and disaster. The O's held true to that prediction,
finishing last in the AL East for the first time since the notorious
1988 season. At the end of that preview, WN wrote
Wacky Neighbor's final take: If in 3-5 years the Orioles are at
least improving and it's at least reasonable to consider the Orioles
getting over .500 in the standings and having a shot at making the playoffs,
then I'll take whatever lumps come this season. If in 2012 we're still
rebuilding, God help us.
So, here we are, half way to 2012 and wondering whether the Orioles are heading in right direction. Are they? Is .500 and playoff contention doable in 2 more years? Or are we headed to another rebuild down the road?
CatcherYou can say whatever you want about Matt Wieters. He's the franchise in Baltimore. All the tools to be an All-Star catcher, the pedigree at Georgia Tech, a few years of destroying every level of the minor leagues. The downside for Wieters at this point is probably that for some reason he can't stick at catcher and becomes a solid middle of the order hitter at first base. The upside seems limitless. WN thinks that 2010 is probably still going to be a developmental year for Wieters, only 24 and his first full-year in the majors, on top of catching a relatively young staff. But it's unlikely that the O's are going to make WN's timeline of contention in 2 years without him developing into a star catcher.
Rather than dwell on Wieters, let's just look at how bad the O's have been at catcher since 1997 (the last year they went to the playoffs). Here are the catchers that led the Orioles in plate appearances each year between 1998 and 2009 with their OPS:
1998: Lenny Webster, .751 (although Chris Hoiles had nearly as many PA and had an OPS of .833)
1999: Charles Johnson, .753 (acquired for Armando Benitez)
2000: Charles Johnson, .934 (wow, much better than WN remembers him)
2001: Brook Fordyce, .590 (unfathomable)
2002: Geronimo Gil, .632
2003: Brook Fordyce, .682
2004: Javy Lopez, .872
2005: Javy Lopez, .780
2006: Ramon Hernandez, .822
2007: Ramon Hernandez, .714
2008: Ramon Hernandez, .714 (not a typo, just consistently mediocre)
2009: Matt Wieters, .753
Obviously, it's been pretty bad. Sometimes it's been downright awful. Matt Wieters, in fact, wouldn't have to play much better to be a noticeable upgrade over what Baltimore has had at catcher. Craig Tatum won the backup job over Chad Moeller.
InfieldBrian Roberts is still the lead-off batter, second baseman, and mainstay of the infield in his 10th season in Baltimore. Of all of the decisions made over the last 10 years, the decision to stick with Roberts over Jerry Hairston turned out to be one of the better ones in Baltimore. That said, Roberts is 32 this year and battling back problems coming out of spring training. So we'll see.
The rest of the infield is patchwork. Literally. The O's signed Miguel Tejada and Garrett Atkins in the off-season as stop-gaps at third base and first base. Tejada is still a decent hitter and was pretty good in Houston last year - whether that carries over to the AL and a new position is the big question. Atkins had a few good years in Colorado before an awful year last year. At 30, he could still bounce back. Still, the O's are moving 2 players out of position and down the defensive spectrum, so it could be rough. Cesar Izturis returns at shortstop for the second year of a two-year deal. Last year he was pretty mediocre at the plate, but was by most measures a very good defensive shortstop - just about what everyone expected.
The bench consists of Julio Lugo (just acquired from St. Louis) and Ty Wiggington. Nolan Reimold has been getting a little work at first, too. While the Orioles have some prospects in the minors (Josh Bell at third, Brandon Snyder and Michael Aubrey at first, Scott Moore at third or maybe shortstop now), none of them are likely to make an impact this year. Of all of these players, Bell probably has the highest upside and might arrive by 2011. WN is optimistic but not really sold on Snyder and doesn't expect Aubrey or Moore to ever be impact players (that said, if Moore can make a go of it at shortstop in AAA this year, he might get a shot in Baltimore next year).
OutfieldAside from Matt Wieters, the outfield is really the strength of the team now and over the next few years. The O's are solid in two spots with Nick Markakis (only 26) in rightfield and Adam Jones (only 24) in centerfield - five-tool, top-of-the-order players. That said, their numbers last year aren't overwhelming (Markakis actually seemed to take a step back) and Baltimore isn't going to move forward very far if they don't, either.
In fact, the best offensive numbers for the entire team may have come from Luke Scott last year. He's been sort of forgotten amidst the youth movement, but he hit the most home runs for Baltimore last year (25) and was one of the top 2 hitters by OPS for the Orioles amongst regulars. Scott is going to be the DH coming into the season, and he may see some time at first base or even left field. At 32, it's likely Scott isn't going to exceed what he has done the last few years, but he's been reliably solid over the last 3 years (since he saw regular playing time) and should be expected to put up similar numbers this year.
Left field is the one place where the Orioles might actually have a surplus of talent. Nolan Reimold actually led the team in OPS last year (.831, which isn't exactly killing the ball), but battled injuries late last year and into spring training. If he can recover, he could develop into a quality power bat for the O's, and at 26, one could expect improvements over the next 2-3 years, too. While Reimold was out, Felix Pie played splendidly down the stretch. Pie, who essentially washed out of the Cubs system, is only 25 this year and showed signs that maybe he's finally put it together last year. (Despite the fact he seems like a speed guy - he stole 118 bases in 632 games in the minors - he actually has a pretty bad success rate (about 62%) and only stole 1 base last year.) Whether there's room for both or not (plus Scott) remains to be seen. That said, it's been awhile since the O's have had anything resembling a surplus.
Speaking of which, it's unclear that career minor leaguer Lou Montanez will ever get a legit shot in the O's outfield, but he's next on the O's depth chart and will start in AAA. After that, it's pretty thin in the minors.
BenchThe bench to start the season will be Craig Tatum (catcher), Julio Lugo (infield), Ty Wiggington (infield), and Felix Pie (outfield). Lugo would likely be the first to see action at second base or shortstop and Wiggington would likely back up first and third base. If they were to go to a 5-man bench later, WN would expect that they would probably bring up someone they could use as a bat off the bench (Lou Montanez probably being the first choice, with Michael Aubrey not on the 40-man roster).
Overall BattingThe O's at least have some potential finally reaching the major leagues. They have 5 players under 27 who all have the potential to be above-average to excellent players: Wieters, Markakis, Jones, Reimold, and Pie. The hope is that they continue to develop this year, that Roberts is healthy and still one of the top second basemen in the league, and that the contributions from Scott, Tejada, and Atkins are enough to make the Orioles a good hitting team. In 2009, the O's were a bit below average for the league, so it's not unrealistic to expect the Orioles to climb at least to the middle of the league with the core of the team improving, if not slightly better than average.
Overall FieldingIn 2009, the O's were generally an average fielding team. The one area in which the O's did particularly well was in the outfield arm categories (which has a lot to do with Markakis). The one area in which the O's did particularly poorly was preventing runners from stealing, giving up the 5th most steals in the AL and having the 2nd worst caught-stealing percentage (22% - although, in fairness, the league average was only 26%). Hopefully Wieters will help with that. Otherwise, the only real question is whether Tejada can successfully make the transition to third base. The O's haven't gone wild on defense like some other teams recently (Seattle, Boston, Oakland), so it's unlikely that they'll be anything more than average again this year.
More on the O's pitching and predictions to come.